Kwong Ball denies lying in Tin Tin murder trial, says coincidences 'a matter of opinion'
Kwong Ball, second defendant in the Tin Tin murder trial, told Hong Kong's High Court he did not lie about disposing of the body. He rejected prosecution suggestions that renting a flat, buying a SIM card and purchasing tools were linked to the murder, calling coincidences 'a matter of opinion'.
The murder trial of Tin Tin continued in the High Court on 19 November, with second defendant Kwong Ball giving evidence. Under cross-examination by senior prosecutor Ms Kwok Sze Lok, Kwong was challenged that several events were not coincidental but linked to Tin Tin's death, including buying a SIM card for third defendant Kwong Kong Chi, renting units at Triumph Arch and Lung Mei Village, and purchasing tools in Shanghai Street.
Kwong said he did not know why he cooked the body and could not recall the disposal process, including why he boiled limbs with carrots and Chinese radishes. He said he had prepared the vegetables to feed stray cats and dogs daily. When the prosecution accused him of lying, Kwong replied he was mentally broken at the time but had not lied.
On renting the Triumph Arch unit, the prosecution suggested he knew Tin Tin would be killed and that the unit could be used for Kwong Kong Chi to hide. Kwong disagreed, saying he rented it because it was suitable, and that Tin Tin had asked Kwong Kong Chi to return to Hong Kong after learning he had a girlfriend, so the unit would give him somewhere to stay.
Regarding the SIM card, the prosecution noted Kwong obtained it for Kwong Kong Chi on the morning of the incident and questioned if that was a coincidence. They also said documents related to the SIM card were found in the Lung Mei Village unit with Kwong Kong Chi's fingerprints, arguing the card was part of preparations to help him. Kwong disagreed, saying the SIM card was not provided after Tin Tin's death, and whether it was a coincidence was 'a matter of opinion'. He insisted the tools bought on Shanghai Street were for renovation and that he rented the Lung Mei Village house because he has diabetes and needed exercise to stay healthy.
Before noon, Kwong Kong Chi began his testimony, saying he moved into the Whampoa unit because he started dating Tin Tin and did not get along well with his father Kwong Ball. He agreed that Tin Tin's mother, Cheung Yin Fa, was gentler, and he learned Hainanese to integrate into the family. He said his previous legal cases were for the family's benefit, to earn more money.