Wednesday, 18 Nov 2026 · Hong Kong Hong Kong and China labour news in English
CLB.org.hk China Labour Bulletin Board
Hong Kong news · dedicated AI coverage 中國勞工資訊板 · Labour, employment, jobs and AI.
Hong Kong

Hong Kong justice secretary proposes amendments to evidence bill

Hong Kong's Secretary for Justice moved amendments to the Evidence (Amendment) Bill 2026 during committee stage, clarifying burden and standard of proof for necessity conditions and anti-abuse provisions in hearsay evidence admissibility. The amendments aim to prevent interpretation disputes and ens

Hong Kong justice secretary proposes amendments to evidence bill

Hong Kong's Secretary for Justice moved a series of amendments to the Evidence (Amendment) Bill 2026 during the committee stage in the Legislative Council on 18 November 2026. The amendments target clauses 55R and 55S in Part IVA of the bill, as well as the heading of Division 5 of that part.

The key amendment concerns clause 55S, which deals with the necessity condition for admitting hearsay evidence. The government proposed revising clause 55S(3) and adding clause 55S(4) to clearly set out two distinct burdens of proof and their applicable standards. Clause 55S(1) specifies five situations where the necessity condition is met, such as when a declarant has died or is unfit to testify due to age, physical or mental condition.

Clause 55S(2) contains an anti-abuse provision preventing a party from creating such situations deliberately to block a declarant from giving oral evidence. Under the revised clause 55S(3), the applicant must prove the existence of a specified situation under clause 55S(1). If the applicant is the prosecution, the standard is beyond reasonable doubt; if the defendant, on the balance of probabilities.

The new clause 55S(4) addresses the anti-abuse provision: any party alleging that the applicant or their representative caused the situation to prevent oral evidence must bear the burden of proof. The standard is beyond reasonable doubt for the prosecution and on the balance of probabilities for the defendant. The secretary said this arrangement follows analysis by the England and Wales Law Commission on hearsay evidence reform, noting that requiring the applicant to prove a negative proposition would be overly burdensome and impractical.

Other amendments include revising the introductory wording of clause 55S(1) for clarity, removing the conjunction 'or' at the end of paragraph (d), and refining Chinese language text in clauses 55R and 55S by adding characters to ensure consistent reference to declarants. The heading of Division 5 of Part IVA is proposed to change from 'Admissibility of certain hearsay evidence and related evidence' to 'Admissibility of evidence relating to credibility and admissibility of previous statements' to better reflect the content of clauses 55W and 55X.

The secretary noted that the Bills Committee had no objection to these amendments and urged members to support them.

Adam
Editor in Chief

Editor in Chief overseeing CLB.org.hk coverage and editorial standards.