Hong Kong court raises hotel cartel fine to HK$950,000 on appeal
Hong Kong's Competition Appeal Court increased a fine for Prudential Hotel (BVI) Limited from HK$104,000 to HK$950,000 for price-fixing. The court ruled the original penalty did not reflect the severity of the conduct or provide deterrence. The Competition Commission said the judgment sends a strong
The Hong Kong Competition Appeal Court has allowed an appeal by the Competition Commission against the penalty imposed on Prudential Hotel (BVI) Limited, the owner and operator of the Harbour Plaza hotel, for price-fixing in breach of the Competition Ordinance. The court increased the fine from HK$104,000 to HK$950,000 and ordered the hotel to pay the commission's legal costs for both the appeal and the earlier tribunal hearing.
The Appeal Court ruled that the original HK$104,000 penalty imposed by the Competition Tribunal did not reflect the seriousness of the hotel's unlawful conduct and was insufficient to provide specific or general deterrence against such behaviour. The higher penalty was therefore necessary.
A spokesman for the Competition Commission said the ruling sends an important message that not only the direct participants but also any third party that facilitates anti-competitive conduct between businesses that should be competing with each other will face legal consequences and penalties. The commission believes the judgment fully reflects the severity of the violations and provides a strong deterrent effect.
The commission initiated proceedings in early 2022 before the tribunal against the hotel and five other defendants, alleging they had engaged in price-fixing when selling tickets for tourist attractions and transport tickets at multiple hotels in Hong Kong. The commission's case alleged that the hotel group, including Prudential Hotel, acted as a "facilitator" by conveying pricing information between two competing tourism service providers, actively assisting in the implementation of the price-fixing arrangement.