Trump's tariffs cast shadow over APEC talks in Shenzhen
APEC talks in Shenzhen are overshadowed by geopolitical rivalries and US tariffs. Experts say cooperation is harder than ever, with Trump 'unleashed' on trade. Other countries are deepening ties without the US, like Canada negotiating a free-trade pact with the Philippines.
The 21-member Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum, gathering in Shenzhen, faces significant headwinds from geopolitical rivalries and US tariff policy, according to analysts. Members include the United States, China, Japan, Russia, Canada, Mexico, Australia and Indonesia.
"Having China serve as host in an institution that includes the United States and Russia has not been a recipe for success," said Deborah Elms, head of trade policy at the Hinrich Foundation in Singapore. "All three are at odds with one another and geopolitical rivalries that cross many members have made cooperation on even relatively benign topics harder than ever," Elms wrote in a research note. She noted that US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent skipped an APEC finance ministers' meeting in Hong Kong in October, depriving others of "the opportunity to connect to a key official from the United States". Elms also criticised China for making "unhelpful changes" to APEC processes, such as moving meetings online and delaying confirmation of key event timings.
There is no sign of a reversal in President Donald Trump's tariff policies, even after the Democrats won control of both houses of Congress in midterm elections on 3 November. The US Supreme Court struck down a host of Trump's customs duties in February, but Washington has since cited inadequate efforts to combat forced labour as grounds for imposing new tariffs — as high as 12.5 per cent — on 60 economies, including APEC members in Asia and Latin America. Sector-specific tariffs on steel, automobiles and timber remain in effect.
Joshua Kurlantzick, senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR), said Trump is "doubling down" and Congress "can't do much about Trump's trade and tariffs, and I don't think Trump is going to change." Kurlantzick added: "He doesn't care also about whether his policies impact GOP favourability, so that kind of makes him unleashed to do whatever he wants in a way."
This has spurred other countries to deepen trade relations without the US. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said on Saturday that Ottawa had concluded negotiations for a free-trade pact with the Philippines, and a broader agreement was in the works with the entire 11-member Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). The pacts were "part of a strategy of developing a dense web of reliable partners to create more opportunities... and reducing our relative reliance on the United States," Carney said.
Brazil's newly re-elected President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, speaking at the ASEAN gathering in Manila on Sunday, said: "Brazil has learned an extraordinary lesson after the US decided to impose tariffs (on other countries). Instead of weeping or begging the US government... to have pity on us, we decided to look for other partners for us to sell and for us to buy from." He noted that trade with Indonesia and Vietnam had jumped 15 and 13 per cent, respectively.
The Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) — a free-trade agreement encompassing China, Southeast Asian nations, Japan, Australia and South Korea — has set long-term targets for tariff reductions. However, Nick Marro, principal Asia economist at the Economist Intelligence Unit, said the agreement's provisions "suffer from weaker enforcement and dispute settlement mechanisms." He told AFP: "While the drive to expand and deepen RCEP will stay, the pact will offer middle powers relatively limited shelter in an increasingly fractious geopolitical landscape—especially amid rising US protectionism and the continued global spillover of China's economic imbalances."